Alexey Ivanov: BRICS Countries Can Play a Key Role in Forming a New Complex Approach to Regulation of Digital Ecosystems
Experts from the HSE BRICS Competition Law & Policy Centre presented a natural approach-based concept for antirust regulation of digital ecosystems at the 7th BRICS International Competition Conference, which took place from 16th to 17th November 2021 in China.
The BRICS International Competition Conference is world’s biggest event on BRICS competition policy. The first conference was held in Kazan in 2009 at the initiative of FAS Russia, and since then, it has been held in different BRICS countries biannually. In 2019, the conference was hosted by Moscow. In 2021, the organizer of the conference was China’s antitrust authority – the State Administration for Market Regulation.
Today, regulators worldwide are trying to fight the problem of the growing market authority of big digital corporations and platforms. But this work is often fragmented and lacks an overall system. ‘Regulatory approaches of the industrial era have collided with a new economic and social phenomenon, which is ecosystems. It’s time to discuss a new integral understanding of antitrust regulation’, explained Alexey Ivanov, Director of the HSE International BRICS Competition Law and Policy Centre and Director of the HSE — Skolkovo Institute for Law and Development. He participated in the panel discussion ‘Development of Competition Policy in the Digital Era’.
Digital platforms and the digital ecosystems that are based on them — supplier and consumer networks forming around one centre — have already taken a key position in the digital economy and are an ‘entrance point’ for suppliers and consumers of goods and services. According to McKinsey, up to $60 trillion, or 30% of all global net sales will be transferred via these ecosystems in 2025. ‘Today’s competition laws need a comprehensive set of methods to evaluate how ecosystems work, how they compete with each other, how internal competition in an ecosystem works, and what opportunities there are for balancing them, without causing their destruction’, Alexey Ivanov explained.
Alexey Ivanov
A complex approach to ecosystem analysis and regulation suggested by the International BRICS Competition Law and Policy Centre uses similarities between natural and digital ecosystems and elaborates regulatory solutions based on an ecological approach to competition. Creators of ecosystems have already faced such a task and successfully solved it. Alexey Ivanov said that the new methodology of antitrust regulation should be inspired by the same principles and views as the business strategies of today’s big digital corporations, ‘which means the principles of wild nature’.
Digital competition models are being developed by the International BRICS Competition Law and Policy Centre together with the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (IIASA). They have already adapted the Lotka-Volterra interspecies competition model. This describes a situation when one or two competitors fight for the same resource. When applied to digital ecosystems, this resource is the users’ time and attention.
Ecosystems follow cycles, and for a business, it is essential to understand what stage of a cycle they are currently at, in order to take the next correct steps: this is a fundamental characteristic that defines a business strategy. But, as Alexey Ivanov said, currently, antitrust regulators continue to work as a mechanism, as an industrial machine: this ignores the cycles and living nature of a business. It is necessary to move to a more consistent model of ecosystems’ antitrust regulation, which would take into account their complexity, the large number of internal connections and their dynamic nature.
Alexey Ivanov believes that BRICS countries can play a very important role in designing a new complex approach to digital ecosystem regulation, which would rely on ‘nature-like solutions’: ‘This complies with the cultural traditions of our countries and, most importantly, can become a useful and effective solution for the problem of the growing disbalance of expanding and complexifying ecosystems across the globe; essentially, it could become a new standard for antitrust regulation in a digital economy’.
As he spoke at the session on competition policy coordination, Mr. Ivanov emphasized the special role of BRICS for developing competition at the global level: ‘The world is lacking an integral antitrust regulation regime today, but hopefully, a transitional scenario could be implemented by BRICS countries’. BRICS is a flexible format, which means that cooperation frameworks can also be flexible within it. Antitrust law is an adaptive regulation tool, which effectively reacts to rapidly-changing conditions. ‘We have an opportunity to elaborate an effective mechanism to coordinate approaches to competition protection through the effort of BRICS countries’, Alexey Ivanov said.
A special session of the conference was dedicated to the problem of cross-border cartels. Anna Pozdnyakova, Research Fellow of the International BRICS Competition Law and Policy Centre, presented the Centre’s outcomes in this research field.
Anna Pozdnyakova
The fight against cross-border cartels is the focus of attention of many international associations today (UNCTAD, OECD, International Competition Network), and BRICS countries agree that it should be strengthened. The International BRICS Competition Law and Policy Centre provides comprehensive support for competition authorities in developing tools to fight this type of anti-competition behaviour, including work as part of the UNCTAD Working Group on Cross-Border Cartels.
‘We have introduced the expert community to the second version of our empirical study on the experience of fighting cross-border cartels, which over 50 competition authorities participated in. This study includes conclusions on the obstacles and difficulties faced by law enforcement authorities in global cartel investigations. We hope that this study will be useful in international decision making’, said Anna Pozdnyakova.
Maxim Shaskolsky, Head of the FAS Russia, at the conference opening ceremony
‘The International BRICS Competition Law and Policy Centre provides essential expert support for the activities of BRICS competition authorities. In 2020, the Centre’s activities were praised by BRICS country leaders, which means that such a partnership is promising. It is important to use the Centre’s capabilities more actively and attract experts for the joint development of advanced solutions for the improvement of antitrust regulation in BRICS countries’.
Позднякова Анна Эдуардовна
See also:
'Staying Open to New Challenges and Opportunities Is Crucial'
The Tenth BRICS Youth Summit was held in Ulyanovsk from July 22 to 26. The event was attended by more than 200 early-career professionals from Brazil, India, China, Egypt, Iran, the United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia, Ethiopia, South Africa, and Russian regions. Participants gathered to discuss current global issues and explore opportunities for youth collaboration. Students of HSE University who attended the Youth Summit shared their impressions with HSE University Life.
HSE University Launches Consortium of BRICS Law Schools
The HSE Faculty of Law hosted an online meeting with law schools and expert centres from BRICS countries. The purpose of the event was to join efforts to advance legal science and practice for the benefit of the organization. To this end, at the initiative of the Dean of the Faculty of Law Vadim Vinogradov, a Consortium of BRICS Law Schools was established, comprising representatives of leading higher education institutions from a number of countries.
‘At HSE University I Had the Opportunity to Meet the Best Academics’
In April 2024, HSE School of International Regional Studies of the Faculty of World Economy and International Affairs organised a round table ‘Russia and the Most Influential Countries of the Global South: Comparing Approaches to the New International Political and Economic-Financial Order’. Seyedmohammad Seyedi Asl, Research Fellow at the School of International Regional Studies, spoke to HSE News Service on his report ‘Global South, BRICS, and Iran's Foreign Policy’ presented at the round table, his research interests and impressions of working at HSE University, and living in Moscow.
‘We Work to Create a More Prosperous, Fair, and Safe World’
On July 3–4, 2024, the IX BRICS Civil Forum was held in Moscow for the first time since the association was expanded by five new countries in January 2024. Participants emphasised the importance of personal interaction between public figures, civil activists, as well as the work they do to strengthen and enrich friendly relations between BRICS countries, based on mutual respect. The forum was organised by the BRICS Expert Council–Russia, which is established at the HSE University.
BRICS Countries Support HSE University’s Project to Launch Fair Competition Platform
A meeting of the BRICS Coordination Committee on Antimonopoly Policy was held in Geneva as part of Russia's BRICS Chairship in 2024. The meeting participants supported a project to launch a BRICS Interstate Platform on Fair Competition, developed by the International BRICS Competition Law and Policy Centre of HSE University and presented by the FAS of Russia as an initiative of the Russian Chairship.
BRICS Academic Forum Held in Moscow
The Forum brought together more than 200 representatives from the expert community across all BRICS countries to discuss the topic ‘BRICS: New Figures at the Global Chessboard.’ The forum was organised by the BRICS Expert Council–Russia, which operates on the basis of HSE University. The event’s opening ceremony featured the representatives of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the State Duma, as well as HSE University Rector Nikita Anisimov and HSE Vice Rector, Russian W20 Sherpa Victoria Panova.
HSE Strengthens Cooperation with India and Creates Opportunities for Dialogue between Experts
Following the visit of the HSE University delegation to New Delhi, cooperation agreements with leading Indian universities were finalised. Similarly, a number of expert events, consultations and negotiations on the development of comprehensive strategic cooperation with Bharat took place. The HSE University delegation also participated in the Raisina Dialogue, one of the largest international expert forums.
HSE Hosts Round Table ‘Africa and BRICS: Reflections and Prospects’
On April 15, 2024 HSE University hosted a roundtable discussion ‘Africa and BRICS: Reflections and Prospects.’ The event featured leading experts from the South African Institute of International Affairs (SAIIA) Steven Gruzd and Gustavo de Carvalho and was moderated by HSE Vice Rector and Head of the BRICS Expert Council–Russia Victoria Panova.
Intellectual Property Issues in the Framework of BRICS Discussed at HSE University
On April 8, a roundtable discussion entitled ‘Intellectual Property on the Rise: How to Maximize Its Positive Impact and Avoid Hazards’ took place at HSE University in Moscow. The participants included Victoria Panova, HSE Vice Rector and Head of the BRICS Expert Council–Russia, andAlan Freeman, Co-Director of Geopolitical Economy Research Group at the University of Manitoba; Secretary of Geopolitical Economy Research and Education Trust; Co-Editor of Geopolitical Economy Book series, Manchester University Press.
‘The Goal of the Contest Is to Select Bold Ideas Aimed at Fostering a More Equitable Global Development’
HSE Vice Rector, Head of the BRICS Expert Council–Russia and Co-chair of the BRICS Civil Forum Victoria Panova, and Dean of the HSE Faculty of Humanities and Chair of the Contest Jury Felix Azhimov, announced the primary objectives of the contest, its format and potential participants during a press conference at TASS. Nationals from the BRICS countries, aged 18 to 45, are eligible to apply for participation in the contest. The jury will select ten winners, three of whom will be given the opportunity to attend the BRICS Civil Forum in Moscow in person.